Psychiatrist vs Psychologist for ADHD: Why Start With a Psychiatrist in New Jersey?
Oxytocin

Medically reviewed by Sireesha Kolli, MD, child and adult psychiatrist. Last updated November 2026.

If you think you have ADHD and want the option of treatment, a psychiatrist is usually the most direct place to start. Psychologists can diagnose ADHD too, but in New Jersey they cannot prescribe medication, so a psychologist’s diagnosis often leads to a second appointment with a prescriber.

A psychiatrist is a medical doctor who can diagnose ADHD, rule out conditions that look like it, and prescribe and manage medication when it is appropriate, all with the same doctor. At Kolli Psychiatric & Associates, every ADHD evaluation is a 60-minute visit with a psychiatrist, at our Red Bank office or by secure telehealth across New Jersey.

Why is a psychiatrist the better first step for most adults with ADHD symptoms?

The CDC notes that psychiatrists, psychologists and primary care providers can all diagnose ADHD. For an adult who may want treatment, a psychiatrist offers four things the others usually cannot offer together.

 

Can a psychiatrist diagnose and treat ADHD with the same doctor?

Yes. A psychiatrist can give the diagnosis, explain the treatment options, prescribe medication if you choose it, and see you for follow-up visits. You do not need a referral to a second clinician.
With a psychologist in New Jersey, that second step is unavoidable if you want medication. As of July 2026, only nine states allow specially trained psychologists to prescribe, and New Jersey is not one of them, according to the American Psychological Association.

 

Can a psychiatrist tell ADHD apart from anxiety, depression or sleep problems?

This is where a psychiatrist’s medical training matters most. The CDC notes that sleep disorders, anxiety, depression and some learning disabilities can have symptoms similar to ADHD.

A psychiatrist can assess both the mental and physical sides of what you are experiencing, according to the American Psychiatric Association. If the answer is ADHD together with anxiety or depression, the same psychiatrist can plan treatment for both.

 

Does a psychiatrist check my other medications and health?

Yes. Because psychiatrists are physicians, they can order medical laboratory tests as well as psychological tests, according to the American Psychiatric Association. Your psychiatrist also reviews the medications and supplements you already take before recommending anything new. Our guide to drug and supplement interactions explains why that matters.

 

Will the same psychiatrist manage my ADHD medication over time?

Yes. If you start medication, the dose is adjusted over the first months at follow-up visits with your psychiatrist, in person in Red Bank or by telehealth. Read more about psychiatric medication management at our practice.
If therapy would help alongside medication, our practice also offers talk therapy, so your care can stay in one place.

 

How does a psychiatrist compare with a psychologist for ADHD?

Psychiatrist  Psychologist
Degree MD or DO (medical doctor) PhD, PsyD, or EdD
Can diagnose ADHD Yes Yes
Can prescribe ADHD medication in New Jersey Yes No
Assesses physical and mental health Yes Mental Health
Manages medication at follow-up visits Yes No
Formal psychological testing Can order it or refer you Often performs it

 

 

Who are the psychiatrists who evaluate adults for ADHD at Kolli Psychiatric?

Every ADHD evaluation at our practice is done by a psychiatrist.

Dr. Sireesha Kolli, Child and Adult Psychiatrist. Medical degree from Drexel University College of Medicine and a Master of Public Health from Emory University. Residency in adult psychiatry and fellowship in child and adolescent psychiatry at Western Psychiatric Institute and Clinic, University of Pittsburgh Medical Center.

Dr. Avinash Puchalapalli, Adult Psychiatrist. Medical degree from Sidney Kimmel Medical College at Thomas Jefferson University. Adult psychiatry residency through the New York Medical College program at Saint Clare’s Denville Hospital and St. Mary’s General Hospital in North Jersey.

Dr. Noah Schwartzman, Child, Adolescent and Adult Psychiatrist. Board certified, with a medical degree from the Philadelphia College of Osteopathic Medicine, psychiatry residency at Delaware Psychiatric Center and a child and adolescent psychiatry fellowship at Thomas Jefferson University Hospital. His areas of focus include ADHD.

Dr. Neha Naqvi, Child, Adolescent and Adult Psychiatrist. Medical degree from the University of Missouri-Kansas City, with residency in adult psychiatry and fellowship in child and adolescent psychiatry at Wake Forest University School of Medicine. She specializes in depression, anxiety and ADHD, among other conditions.

Meet all of our providers

 

What happens at an adult ADHD evaluation with a psychiatrist in Red Bank, NJ?

There is no single test for ADHD, according to the CDC. Your psychiatrist builds the diagnosis from your symptoms, your history and how symptoms affect your daily life.

For adults, the National Institute of Mental Health explains that symptoms must have started before age 12, and that adults need five symptoms of inattention or of hyperactivity and impulsivity, instead of the six required for children. That is why your psychiatrist asks about childhood as well as the present.

At Kolli Psychiatric, the evaluation works like this:

Book your visit. Choose an in-person visit at our Red Bank office or a telehealth visit from anywhere in New Jersey.

Prepare. Bring a list of your medications and, if you have them, old report cards or past evaluations.

A 60-minute evaluation with your psychiatrist. Your psychiatrist asks about focus, organization and restlessness now and in childhood, plus sleep, mood, anxiety, substance use, medical history and current medications.

Your results and plan. Your psychiatrist explains whether you meet the criteria for ADHD, whether another condition explains your symptoms better, and what your treatment options are.

Follow-up, if you start treatment. Medication is adjusted at follow-up visits with the same psychiatrist.

Our adult ADHD evaluation page covers each step in more detail.

 

How much does an ADHD evaluation with a psychiatrist cost at Kolli Psychiatric?

These fees come from our fees page. Telehealth and in-person visits are billed at the same rates.

Visit Length Fee
ADHD Evaluation (all ages) Up to 60 minutes $500
Follow-up visit Up to 25 minutes $315
Follow-up visit Up to 45 minutes $420

 

 

Can I get reimbursed by my insurance?

We are out-of-network with all insurance plans. You pay at the time of your visit, and we send you an itemized receipt, called a superbill, through the patient portal so you can submit it to your insurer.

If your plan has out-of-network mental health benefits, it may reimburse part of the fee once your deductible is met. Our fees page shows an example: with a plan that reimburses 70%, a $500 evaluation would cost you about $150. Reimbursement depends on your plan and is not guaranteed. Our out-of-network guide has more detail, and the fees page lists five questions to ask your insurer before your visit.

 

When is a psychologist or neuropsychological testing the right choice?

A psychiatric evaluation is enough to diagnose ADHD for most adults. Formal testing with a psychologist or neuropsychologist helps in specific situations:

  • A learning disability is suspected alongside ADHD. The NIMH notes that psychological tests can identify strengths, challenges and possible learning disabilities.
  • A testing agency or school asks for objective test data, as some standardized and professional exams do. Our page on ADHD evaluations for accommodations explains when this applies.
  • You want therapy or skills work focused on ADHD, which psychologists and therapists provide.

We do not do neuropsychological testing in-house. If your psychiatrist thinks testing would help, we refer you to trusted neuropsychologists in New Jersey and continue your care with us. Read more about neuropsychological testing for ADHD.

If a psychologist has already diagnosed you, you can book with one of our psychiatrists to discuss treatment. Bring the report with you.

 

Is a local psychiatrist better than an online ADHD service?

Online services can be convenient, but they vary in who evaluates you and who follows up. A local psychiatric practice gives you the choice of in-person or telehealth visits and the same psychiatrist at every follow-up.

There is also a rule change to watch. Most ADHD stimulants are controlled medications. A federal extension lets them be prescribed by audio-video telemedicine without a prior in-person visit through December 31, 2026, and a permanent rule has not been finalized. With an office in Red Bank, our patients can switch to in-person visits if the telehealth rules change. Read more about our telehealth psychiatry appointments.

 

Frequently asked questions about seeing a psychiatrist for ADHD

 

Can a psychiatrist diagnose ADHD?

Yes. A psychiatrist is a medical doctor who can diagnose ADHD in adults and children, check for conditions with similar symptoms, and prescribe medication when it is appropriate.

 

Can a psychologist diagnose ADHD?

Yes, but in New Jersey a psychologist cannot prescribe medication. If you want to consider medication after a psychologist’s diagnosis, you will need a visit with a prescriber, such as a psychiatrist.

 

Who can diagnose ADHD in adults?

A psychiatrist, a psychologist or a primary care provider, according to the CDC. A psychiatrist is the best fit when you may want medication, when symptoms overlap with anxiety, depression or sleep problems, or when earlier treatment did not help.

 

 How much does an adult ADHD evaluation cost in New Jersey?

At Kolli Psychiatric, an ADHD evaluation is $500 for a visit of up to 60 minutes with a psychiatrist. We are out-of-network and provide a superbill you can submit for possible reimbursement. See our fees page for follow-up fees and a reimbursement example.

 

Can I have an ADHD evaluation by telehealth in New Jersey?

Yes. You can be evaluated by secure video from anywhere in New Jersey, or in person at our Red Bank office. Fees are the same for both.

 

Can a psychiatrist diagnose ADHD in one visit?

Often, yes. If your history is clear, your psychiatrist can usually tell you at the end of the first visit whether you meet the criteria. Sometimes a second visit, rating scales or input from someone who knew you as a child is needed first.

 

What questions does a psychiatrist ask in an ADHD evaluation?

Expect questions about focus, organization, restlessness and impulsivity, now and in childhood. Your psychiatrist will also ask about sleep, mood, anxiety, alcohol and other substance use, medical conditions, current medications, and how symptoms affect your work and relationships.

 

How soon can I see a psychiatrist for ADHD?

Call 732-655-4568 or book online, and our team will match you with a psychiatrist.

 

Ready to book an ADHD evaluation with a psychiatrist in New Jersey?

If you think you have ADHD and want one doctor who can diagnose it, rule out other causes and manage treatment, our psychiatrists can help. We see adults in person in Red Bank and by telehealth across New Jersey. Book an adult ADHD evaluation or call 732-655-4568.

 

See a Top-Rated Psychiatrist in NJ

Thoughtful psychiatric evaluations and medication management for children, teens, and adults in Red Bank, Monmouth County, and through telehealth across New Jersey.